Spooky Halloween Spider Cookies Recipe (2024)

This post may contain affiliate links. See my disclosure policy for more details.

These Spooky Halloween Spider cookies are so fun to make with mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and delicious cookies!

Halloween Spider Cookies

Aren’t they the cutest?? I love simple and I love fun halloween treats. These easy Halloween cookies are one of our Halloween favorites!

These Spooky Spider cookies are so fun to make (the kids will love helping you) and they also make for a fun treat to bring to Halloween parties and gatherings.

The kids love the little eyeballs and all of the spooky (ok, cute!) spider cookies look awesome on the table and are a quick easy treat that will go perfectly with your decor! So much fun!

Items Needed to make Spider Cookies

Any type of cookie will work. You can use homemade cookies, or if you are in a rush, pre-made cookie dough (or even store bought cookies) can work.
Mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (make sure to get the mini peanut butter cup size)
Candy Eyes
Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips

How to make Spider Cookies

Bake cookies as directed. As you pull them out of the oven use a teaspoon-measuring spoon to make divots in the middle of the cookie and then allow the cookies to cool completely.

While you are waiting for your cookies to cool, placeacupof chocolate chips in a bowl and microwave them in intervals of 12 seconds until they are completely melted. You will use this melted chocolate to drizzle the spider legs onto the cookies.

We love these chocolate chip spider cookies but a close second favorite for Halloween are peanut butter spider cookies, made exactly the same way! If you are really in a rush, we’ve also made these using pre-made dough (sugar cookies are yummy and you can find that dough in the refrigerated section at the grocery store)

Make The Spider Body and Legs

To create the spider body, place your Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups in the middle of the cookie where your divot is. Make sure to get the peanut butter cup right in the center of each cookie.

Next, add the candy eyes by placing a dap of melted chocolate on the back of the candy eyeballs you can stick them into place on the peanut butter cups. Make sure your candy eyes are firmly in place before continuing.

Lastly, use your meltedchocolate to drizzle the chocolate spiders legs onto the cookies which will finish the spider’s body. Run your chocolate off the side of the cookies from the Reese’s cups to the bottom of the cookies.

*Just make sure that you allow the cookies to cool after whatever cookie recipes you use. A too warm cookie will cause the chocolate legs to run, so wait to do that step on the top of each cookie until the cookies have sat on the cooling rack for a bit.

I used the smallest tip on my Wilton cake decorating set to draw the legs with the chocolate frosting / melted chocolate.

Let the melted chocolate dry on top of the cookies before you serve them – you might even want to put them in the fridge to set up a bit.

These easy Halloween spider cookies are such a fun Halloween treat that is also one of our favorite recipes to make during the fall and this is a recipe that the kids will love helping with as well! Fun Halloween desserts are one of my favorite things about this time of year and nothing says Happy Halloween like gross food recipes, am I right?

My kids get the biggest kick out of Halloween dessert ideas like this and I love this particular recipes because it’s so simple – so fun and it’s easy to make and has an easy cleanup as well!

Print the Recipe for these Cute Halloween Cookies

Halloween Treat: Spooky Spider Cookies

Perfect for Halloween, these spooky spider cookies will be a hit at your Halloween party! Easy to make, they also look wonderful on your Halloween party table!

Ingredients

• Any type of cookie will work. You can use homemade cookies, or if you are in a rush, pre-made cookie dough (or even store bought cookies) can work.
• Mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
• Candy Eyes
• Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips

Instructions

Bake Cookies as directed. As you pull them out of the oven use a teaspoon-measuring spoon to make divots in the middle of the cookie and then allow the cookies to cool completely.
While you are waiting for your cookies to cool, place a cup of chocolate chips in a bowl and microwave them in intervals of 12 seconds until they are completely melted. You will use this melted chocolate to drizzle the legs onto the cookies.
Now place Your Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups in the middle of the cookie where your divot is. By placing a dap of melted chocolate on the back of the candy eyes, you can then stick them into place on the peanut butter cups. Lastly, use your melted chocolate to drizzle the spiders legs onto the cookies. I used the smallest tip on my Wilton cake decorating set. Let the melted chocolate dry.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Facebook

Looking for other fun and spooky Halloween party ideas?

Kids will always get SO much candy for Halloween so it’s fun to bring in a few non-candy Halloween treats or recipe ideas to kind of balance things out.

Make sure to check out my Spiderweb Soup recipe or my Deviled Egg Spider Recipes. OR, if you are looking for something truly gross, how about my Dirty Ear Wax Q-Tip treats (shown below and not for the faint of heart!) … happy baking and haunting!

MORE Favorite Halloween Recipes & Crafts

If you are looking for more fun Halloween recipe and craft ideas, make sure to check out these favorites:

Yummy Spider Webs Treat + FREE Printable

Easy Halloween Jack O’Lantern Quesadilla

Easy Halloween Jack O’Lantern Burgers

Spooky Halloween Donuts with Teeth

Halloween Mummy Candle Holder Craft